Comparative analysis of GIS (part 2)
Updated: Nov 19, 2021
Russia’s Renewable Energy Sources
According to the description provided on the “Renewable Energy Sources” GIS (RRES GIS) official website  the project is accomplished in cooperation with following scientific research centers:
Moscow State University’s Faculty of Geography
Joint Institute for High Temperatures of the Russian Academy of Sciences, (research institute in the fields of high energy densities physics, shock wave physics, thermodynamics databases, numerical simulations and cluster computing, dusty plasma, applied electrodynamics, combustion, green power (JIHT))
Renewable Energy Sources and Energy Conservation Laboratory.
Data provided on the website is based on the Global Atlas for Solar energy in Russia and climate databases (special datasets applied in renewable energy monitoring in Russia). Data provided by the GIS may also be used in constructing mathematical models, including dynamic ones, of power stations working on renewable energy.
The Global Atlas for Solar energy in Russia is a set of maps of total solar radiation on the whole surface of Russia. Mean values of solar radiation are calculated from radiation sums of different periods of time. It should be noticed that the data format is defined by heliotechnical equipment requirements . Data for the Global Atlas is provided by Russian weather stations (multiyear solar radiation measurements), Meteonorm RetScreen и NASA SSE(NASA Surface meteorology and Solar Energy) databases. Data taken from NASA SSE, is satellites measurements values used to calculate the Earth's Radiation Energy Balance. Using these values solar radiation distribution models are developed. In these models the following weather parameters are considered:
Earth's surface albedo
Humidity in air
Atmospheric aerosols concentration
Together all these parameters allow determining mean solar radiation streams with a little inaccuracy. It still should be mentioned that these parameters have been calculated in accordance with USA surface specifications .
On the basis of NASA SSE datasets wind annual average velocities distribution maps have been constructed (50 and 10 m heights), which are also included in the Global Atlas. These are map are essential in calculating wind velocities in different regions of Russia. Data taken from the maps is later used in defining power stations’ potential efficiency (including those ones that are integrated into combined solar and wind power stations). Nevertheless, due to the dependency of actual wind velocity and direction from the region’s geographic conditions, it is obligatory to verify all the data, i.e. wind parameters are measured directly at the site of the planned power station. Multiyear data of the surrounding weather station may also be taken into consideration.
Thus, data used in ‘Russia’s Renewable Energy Sources’ GIS is a special dataset that includes statistical information and results of processing this data.
Statistical data is obtained from weather stations all over the country and from the NASA SSE weather database, created on the basis of long-term surface observations with Earth satellites.
Using this statistical data direct (beam), diffuse and reflected solar radiation indices have been calculated for multidirectional horizon degrees and different time periods (including the daily distribution indices of the total amount of solar radiation striking the horizontal surface on the earth).
All these indices may be used afterwards to evaluate the efficiency of solar power stations working on luminescent solar concentrators.
As the studied GIS uses raster map representation the following features fully describe the system visualization policy. Firstly, the whole area is covered by grid with equal-size cells. Location of every cell is calculated simultaneously relatively to the origin of the matrix. The majority feature is an attribute. Every cell on the grid is assigned a single value in the cell (e.g. land use type) in accordance with its majority attribute. This is how the attributes are recorded. Among the advantages it is possible to mention its simplicity. The system is relatively easy and fast to implement. All the calculations overlay and analysis are done fast because of the grid structure. Thus, in order to calculate certain value it is only needed to combine the corresponding cells.
The upper left of the grid is commonly defined as its origin, but there are certain features to be mentioned:
State Plane and Universal Transverse Mercator UTM have their orign at the lower left
Latitude/longitude and Cartesian coordinates are defined to have an origin at the center
There are certain notations that are commonly applied while constructing the raster model, as class, zone and neighborhood:
class is a combination of cells with the similar value (values may be defined by the object type, as for example the cells defining sandy soil, i.e. having the same type)
unlike the class a zone is a combination of contiguous cells having the similar value
neighborhood is a combination of cells adjacent to a target cell(cells may be adjacent in a certain systematic manner)
All the maps provided by the system may be divided into several categories.
Maps are also divided with the respect to the energy sources they are representing. Thus, all the maps are divided into solar, wind, hydro and bio energy. The division is provided explicitly and is highly understandable.
From the point of view of representation concepts the majority of the maps are raster with a certain number of vector maps. It should be mentioned that this division is not unequivocal (i.e. there is no separation evident to the user). Yet, it is possible to find these categories as subdivisions. Thus, there are raster, resource and object maps.
National Renewable Energy Laboratory, NREL
The National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) is the main USA scientific laboratory center implementing researches on renewable energy, efficient energy use (or energy efficiency) and sustainable development.
All the data obtained during the researches is freely available on www.nrel.gov. The data has been visualized, but especially for the power station engineers, it is also available in a table format. All the information presented on the official website has been obtained from one of three research centers:
The National Center for Photovoltaics
The National Bioenergy Center
The National Wind Technology Center - NWTC
All the data obtained during field and indoor measurement is published at Renewable Resource Data Center. For instance, 10 km data maps show hourly solar activity data obtained from field weather stations, daily data on snow coverage, monthly air humidity data, data on greenhouse gases, and a total amount of aerosols in atmosphere in order to let calculate daily surface insolation level. The same maps, but with 40 km data provide information on cloud coverage, atmosphere higher levels humidity, greenhouse gases concentration and a total amount of aerosols in atmosphere in order to allow calculation of the total insolation level. It is still should be mentioned that satellite data is to be verified by field measurements whenever it is possible. For example, a cloud map is an height year histogram of satellite data taken in a 40 x 40 km resolution. Thus, the accuracy and the space map resolution are defined by the database itself .
Besides providing raster maps the NREL represents some data by means of vector model. To create its raster model NREL commonly applies square or rectangular grid. Naturally, that square grid (creating each cell with equal length sides) is conceptually much simpler than any other. In this case, it is possible to divide cells recursively into squares (cells) of same shape. The location is defined by neighborhood, i.e. left/right, above/below directions. This is commonly referred as rook’s case. As all the cells (at least neighborhood ones) are equidistant, the calculation may be simplified. It is also possible to apply a queen’s case, meaning that neighborhood includes 8 connections (including diagonals), But in this case all the cells may not be equidistant. Diagonal cells are 1.41 points away from the cell center (square root of 2).
For example NREL wind data (50 meter height above ground/surface) is obtained from original raster data that varied in resolution from 200-meter to 1000-meter cell sizes. Then, this data have been modified to produce geographic shapefiles. Thus, these shapefiles have been applied to create 50 meter wind maps. There are two distinct groups of data provided in this section: data produced by NREL and data produced by AWS Truepower but validated by NREL.
NREL provides datasets that may be later modified by other tools. For example solar data of Colorado is provided as a shape file that is later possible to be used in such tools as QGIS. In QGIS this shape file may be added as vector layer. These shapefiles are geometry records and attributes corresponding to each record. The information about records/columns and their explication are provided in the metadata. In order to visualize dataset provided by NREL it is necessary to use data based on attributes.
It should be also mentioned that points are commonly referenced as nodes (and arcs as lines). To sum up, it is possible to define key features common to different representation tools.
As it has been mentioned above the polygon edges are described by listing ID numbers like walking around the outside boundary of the area. There is also another file that contains information of all the points and their respective coordinates (an array of IDs). The second file’s efficiency is proved by the following reasons:
there is a problem with the duplicate coordinates and double borders; using the second file helps to solve this problem
as there is a list of IDs in the second file lines can be manipulated directly as polygons, but still there is a proble with networks representation
even if the second data file gives sufficient information there is still lack of topological data
the second generation mapping package, from the Laboratory for Computer Graphics and Spatial Analysis at Harvard, called CALFORM was the first to apply second data file in their vector model.
Unlike ‘Russia’s Renewable Energy Sources’ GIS the maps provided by NREL are explicitly divided into several categories.
Maps. The team responsible for map development is NREL's Geospatial Data Science Team that creates tools for various renewable energy sources and for certain specific tasks (e.g. certain projects). As a benefit to the public, a majority of static maps are offered and Google Map (KML/KMZ) files on a tool called MapSearch To be beneficial for the public a majority of static maps and Google Map files (KML/KMZ) are available on a special tool created by NREL and called MapSearch. The main categories of maps in a public access are:
The biomass resources in the United States data provided in the map form shows the information throughout the county. .
– Federal Energy Management Program
The main goal of the Federal Energy Management Program (FEMP) in cooperation with with Geospatial Analysis staff at NREL was to update the analysis for the development project. Working together they have finally composed an interactive FEMP Screening Map application. Nevertheless, the earlier map versions have been saved and archived. Thus all of them are still available and may be accessed by contacting the NREL’s Webmaster.
There are available maps showing not only favorable resources for enhanced geothermal systems, but also identified hydrothermal sites. Besides providing data on currently developed projects there are also sites on the map showing the planned geothermal power plant projects.
A tool known as GIS modeling is applied in analyzing and visualizing the spatial relationship between supply and demand. For instance, supply in the form of resources (renewable and traditional), hydrogen production facilities, and transportation infrastructure, from one side and hydrogen demand centers from another. This tool is a powerful facility allowing processing large and complex datasets, siting hydrogen production facilities and refueling stations on the map, and analyzing diversity of resources for hydrogen production throughout the United States.
NREL provide powerful analysis Geospatial Toolkits and maps created in collaboration with with various countries. The maps are available through the MapSearch tool and as a separate category on the official web site (international maps).
Marine and Hydrokinetic Maps
There are several viable sites of marine and hydrokinetic resources in the United States. Maps of marine and hydrokinetic (MHK) resources are available on the NREL’s website. Some of them are: Nonpowered Dams Assessment, Wave Resource Assessment, Tidal Streams Resource Assessment, Wave Energy Resource Atlas, and Tidal Streams Resource Maps .
Data for solar maps (solar radiation resources) has been obtained via several photovoltaic collector orientations in the United States. Among the available maps are: PV Solar Radiation Maps, Direct Normal Solar Radiation Maps, Map of U.S. Solar Measurement Station Locations, and the United States Solar Atlas.
The wind power density is the main factor determining the wind resource potential. Thus, wind maps are based on these calculations. The wind energy resources are estimated for the maps and are represented as maps. The data is available only for the United States and its territories. It should be mentioned that these maps indicate general areas where a high wind resource may exist.
International Renewable Energy Agency, IRENA
Created in 2009 the organization’s main goal is to develop and support the renewable energy sources utilization. The organization is aimed to provide a free access to the renewable energy sources data for public and for potential power station developers. IRENA was established on the 26-th of January, 2009 in Bonn, Germany, when 75 states signed an IRENA official statute, which entered into force on the 8-th of July, 2010. IRENA is promoting sustainable development, usage of renewable energy and distributes all the obtained knowledge in order to increase the interest rate in this particular field .
Data visualized on the IRENA is taken from different international sources the majority of which belong to NREL and Global Geographic catalogues as Wind resource maps of the Global Atlas, USA bioenergy data, Full Merra dataset, Spanish National Renewable Energy Centre (CENER) - www.cener.com,World Data base on Protected Areas, WDPA http://www.protectedplanet.net/country/KZ) .
Certain generic models used inn IRENA are implemented by several software vendors in specific computer file formats As IRENA represents data in raster and vector format (including data provided by NREL), there is a set of specific file formats commonly applied during data representation.
Coverage: specific vector data format developed in 1981 by ArcInfo
coverage format supports multiple physical files (approximately 12) in a single folder
this data format is proprietary, thus there are published specifications allowed and for any change ArcInfo is required
Shape ‘file’: specific vector data format developed in 1993 by ArcView
extensions supported: .shp, .shx, .dbf; shape file data format comprises several physical disk files (3 and more); it is required for all of the files to be present
· open-source, thus it is allowed to publish own specifications; commonly used by other vendors
Geodatabase: specific vector data format created in 2000 by ArcGIS 8.0
geodatabase supports multiple layers saved in a single file with .mdb extension (similar to MS Access)
geodatabase format is proprietary; being a recently introduced data format, it is commonly referred as the next generation spatial data file format
The following map systems are used for data representation:
Google Hybrid Map
Google Satellite Map
Google Street Map
Google Terrain Map
Bing Satellite Map
Bing Street Map
Open Street Map
The comparative analysis of different GIS is an essential part of defining proper functional parameters and requirements needed for creating a renewable energy monitoring system. A brief overview of existing GIS and their comparative analysis allow determining the following requirements list:
Data gathering. As it has been mentioned above the NASA SSE datasets prove to be sufficiently accurate and satisfy all the requirements. But still, all the GIS have their own weather stations (or at least data of field actinometrical measurements) to verify the NASA data. Thus, it is strongly recommended to obtain local weather data along with using open source information.
Data visualization and shape files. It has been mentioned that certain GIS provide their own shape files to be later used in other visualization platforms. In this case the data on local renewable energy sources is platform independent and allows the information to be later used for further researches.
As the renewable energy monitoring system is used both for public and professional usage it is necessary to provide raster data for public (for easier access) and vector data for developers and researchers (for more accurate calculations).
Maps. During the overview the problem of inexplicit map categorization has been revealed as it is quite possible for user to be confused. Consequently, the maps are to be explicitly divided by quality and by energy types (as on the NREL website).
To sum up, it is possible to claim that for regions with high renewable energy potential the problem of energy monitoring is considered as an essential part of further development. In case of lack of field measurements the idea of using open source along with field actinometrical measurements on the certain (or existing) sites seems to be efficient from the point of view of accuracy and costs. In this case, the renewable energy monitoring systems may be considered as the strong foundation for alter development of alternative energy in the regions with high potential and high energy demands.
 Fernandez Pierna, J.A. Combination of Support Vector Machines (SVM) and Near Infrared (NIR) imaging spectroscopy for the detection of meat and bone meat (MBM) in compound feeds // Journal of Chemometrics. -2004. -#18. – 349 p.
 "Russia’s Renewable Energy Sources" GIS // http://gisre.ru/menu-about: 3.04.2015
 Yohanis,Y; Popel,O; Frid,S; Norton.B Geographic Variation of Solar Water Heater Performance in Europe // Proceedings of the I MECH E Part A. // Journal of Power and Energy. – 2006. – Vol.220, No. 4. – P. 395-407.
 The NASA Surface Meteorology and Solar Energy Data Set // http://eosweb. larc.nasa.gov/sse: 18.07.2015
 "NREL Photovoltaic Research Home". Photovoltaic Research // http://www.nrel.gov/pv/: 25.07.2015
 NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY NREL – 25 Years of Research Excellence 1977–2002 // http://www.nrel.gov/docs/gen/fy02/30845.pdf : 21.07.
 The NASA Surface Meteorology and Solar Energy Data Set // http://eosweb. larc.nasa.gov/sse: 18.07.2015
 EUROSOLAR-Memorandum zur Einrichtungeiner Internationalen Agentur für Erneuerbare Energien (IRENA) // http://www.eurosolar.de: 3.05.2001
 Abu Dhabi News. Speedier adoption of renewable energy mooted to offset climate change // http://www.abudhabinews.net/index.php/sid/225556185: 9.09.2014
 О.С.Попель, С.Е.Фрид, Ю.Г.Коломиец, и др.Атлас ресурсов солнечной энергии на территории России. М.: ОИВТ РАН, 2010.85 с.
 Ishmanov A.O., Alikhojayev I.B. Spatial data consolidation for decision support in the field of green energy // The International conference information technologies and management. – Riga: Information Systems Management Institute, 2015. – P. 90-91.